Tonight's episode of House conveniently gave me the opportunity to rant on one of my favourite rant-topics.
"Sex is mechanical. Emotion is emotional."
Now, let me say first that I have no problems with porn stars, escorts, fetish models, or any other sex workers. There is a market for what they do, and believe it or not many of them are doing sex work because they want to, not because they're addicts, slaves, or otherwise victims. The people who are forced into sex work represent an entirely separate issue, and right now I'm just talking about those in the industry voluntarily. With that out of the way, let me address the claim that sex work (in this case porn) involves divorcing sex from emotion. In short, I do not believe that is possible.
Emotion is driven by physical triggers. To start with, there is sheer physical proximity. Most people have some notion of "personal space," and would prefer not be touched by someone they're not comfortable with. In fact, most of us don't even want to be near somebody we don't like. Sexual congress is thus, to the reasonable person, an emotionally intimate activity because it is so very physically intimate. This isn't to say one has to be in love (however you define that) with a person you have sex with, but if you dislike them, the psychological repercussions can be severe.
There is also the conditioning that occurs whenever pleasure is associated with a particular event. While by all accounts it isn't as much fun getting it on professionally as some might think, there is undoubtedly a certain level of pleasure involved. After all, you can't have an orgasm without actually having an orgasm. And pleasurable sensations caused by a particular person will inevitably be associated with that person. If someone makes you feel good every time you see them, you are likely going to look forward to seeing them again - and that's emotion.
It is obviously possible to have sex without committing to a romantic relationship, but there is no way to take the emotion out of it. When people talk about separating sex from emotion, they mean separating sex from obligation. Whether or not that's possible is a question of ethics, not of facts.